Lately, I’ve been reflecting on the ethical implications of my role as a brand strategist, especially how we use empathy in strategy. I’d be lying if I said it doesn’t give me pause.
Empathy is a core part of a strategist’s job. Understanding people–what they want, need, aspire to and fear–is central to influencing their thoughts, feelings, behaviors, and actions. And that influence is becoming easier to exert. Today, we have more access than ever before to behavioral data and psychological tools to change hearts and minds. And AI is already making this even faster and amplifying this even more.
But just because we can do these things, should we? And to what end? Who are we really serving? Are we using empathy to improve lives or merely to manipulate?
There are no simple answers here. Our work exists to serve business goals, and with that comes a set of tensions we can’t ignore. But I do think it is our responsibility as strategists to ask ourselves: Where does my own ethical line fall? What am I comfortable with? What am I not willing to do?
Then I came across Michael Ventura’s New York Times piece, “The Dark Side of Empathy.” He articulated this much more clearly. While the entire piece is great, here are some of the key points that resonated with me:
1. “Empathy is not the same as compassion. At its core, empathy is the ability to understand others’ perspectives — what they feel, what they think, what they fear, what they want. That understanding can be wielded in service of a greater good. Or it can be exploited…[W]hat we’re reckoning with now — is what happens when an understanding of human behavior is used not to uplift or support but to provoke or destabilize.”
2. “But this perspective is not only ethically bankrupt; it’s also deeply impractical for leadership, particularly in business. Toxic workplace culture, not compensation, is the leading reason for employee turnover. Empathy, applied with ethical integrity, is a driver of performance, not a drag on it.”
3. “Empathy that connects, that builds, that heals requires a code of ethics. It requires restraint. It requires trust…. When empathy becomes unmoored from ethics, it becomes coercion with a smile.”
The empathy we use as strategists is powerful. But how we choose to use it—and why—matters.
